The Price of Nice: How Good Intentions Maintain Educational Inequality
Edited by Angelina Castagno (University of Minnesota Press, 2019)
Ideologies are the air we breathe, invisible until named. Angelina Castagno’s edited book, The Price of Nice: How Good Intentions Maintain Educational Inequality, gives name to socialized niceness, a common and particularly problematic ideology with real implications for classrooms, students, and communities.
The chapters in The Price of Nice can be read sequentially or out of order, providing readers with a clear understanding of what niceness is and how it actively works against educational justice in K-16 settings. Using stories, data, and theory, the contributing authors demonstrate how niceness demands that we avoid topics that cause discomfort, such as bias, racism, and ableism. Instead, we smile and agree to keep the peace, prioritizing amenability over criticality and justice. Chapters provide concrete examples of how niceness causes harm and how it permeates individuals, schools, and society in insidious ways. Niceness also promotes “color-blindness,” which erases many students’ lived experiences and identities and upholds whiteness.
As white women, we have been socialized into viewing niceness as a positive and desirable trait. However, Castagno’s book helps us recognize that niceness is a set of behaviors and language that is detrimental to justice, allowing “nice folks” to opt out of doing the hard work of disrupting inequities by prioritizing comfort at all costs. This book shines a light on this “invisible” and detrimental ideology, calling to action those dedicated to dismantling white supremacy.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Nina F. Weisling
Nina F. Weisling is a chair and assistant professor of education at Carthage College, Kenosha, WI. She is a co-author of Responsive Mentoring: Supporting the Teachers All Students Deserve (Rowman & Littlefield, 2020).
Wendy Gardiner
Wendy Gardiner is the Jolita Benson Endowed Chair of Elementary Education at Pacific Lutheran University in Tacoma, WA.
